Crate Almanac

Guides

Sampling

A sample is a piece of an existing recording reused in a new one. Hip hop did not invent the idea, but it built a whole method of composition on it, growing directly from the DJ's habit of repeating the best part of someone else's record. This guide covers how sampling replaced the studio band and the drum machine, the dense collages of the late 1980s, the court cases that made licensing compulsory, and the techniques producers developed in response.

From replayed disco to the sampled break

The first rap records could not use the DJ's method directly. Labels such as Sugar Hill Records hired studio bands to replay the grooves that DJs had been cutting up, so "Rapper's Delight" in 1979 rests on a re-recording of "Good Times" by Chic, whose writers obtained a credit after threatening to sue. From 1982 the drum machine took over, and "Planet Rock" replayed melodies by Kraftwerk on synthesizers over a programmed beat. Digital samplers existed, but the early ones cost many thousands of dollars and held a second or two of sound.

Cheaper machines changed that in the mid 1980s. Marley Marl, a Queens producer and radio DJ, found that a sampler could lift a single kick or snare from an old record and that those sounds, triggered in a new pattern, had a weight no drum machine matched. Within two years producers were sampling whole bars. The samplers of 1987 and 1988 could hold a loop of a break, and compilations such as Ultimate Breaks & Beats put the best-known drum passages, from "Funky Drummer" by James Brown to "Amen, Brother" by The Winstons, in every producer's hands.

The collage years

Between 1987 and 1991 there was little to restrain what producers took, and albums were built from dozens or hundreds of sources. The Bomb Squad's productions for Public Enemy on It Takes A Nation Of Millions To Hold Us Back layered sirens, speeches, horn stabs and several drum loops at once into a deliberate wall of noise. Prince Paul's work on 3 Feet High And Rising by De La Soul drew on children's records, language lessons and soft rock, and the Dust Brothers assembled Paul's Boutique for the Beastie Boys from more than 100 records.

The method had a logic beyond economy. A sample carries the sound of a particular room, tape machine and player, and recombining such fragments produced textures no band could. It also made the producer a kind of archivist. Crate digging, the search through secondhand shops for unused records, became a competitive craft, and the choice of source, whether funk, Blue Note jazz or library music, signaled allegiance. Jazzy Hip-Hop and much of what the catalog files as Boom Bap come out of this practice.

The lawsuits

Licensing had been informal and often skipped. In 1989 two former members of The Turtles sued De La Soul over a short passage of their recording "You Showed Me" used in an interlude, and the case was settled out of court. In December 1991, in Grand Upright Music v. Warner Bros. Records, a federal judge in New York ruled that Biz Markie had infringed copyright by using part of "Alone Again (Naturally)" by Gilbert O'Sullivan without permission, opened his opinion with the biblical commandment against stealing and referred the matter for possible criminal prosecution. The album was withdrawn from sale.

After that decision every label required sample clearance before release, which means a license from the owner of the recording and another from the owner of the song. In 2004 the appeals court in Bridgeport Music v. Dimension Films, a case about a two-second guitar chord from a Funkadelic record used by N.W.A., held that even the smallest sample of a sound recording needs a license, and it confirmed the ruling on rehearing in 2005. Other courts have since disagreed, but industry practice has followed the stricter rule. Unresolved rights kept the early De La Soul albums off digital services until 2023.

How clearance changed the sound

The cost of licensing reshaped production within a few years. Collage on the scale of 1988 became unaffordable, and most tracks settled on one or two cleared samples. Dr. Dre had musicians replay Parliament-Funkadelic parts for The Chronic in 1992, a practice called interpolation, which needs only the song license and not the recording. Sean Combs took the opposite course at Bad Boy Entertainment, paying for long, recognizable passages of 1980s hits and treating the familiarity as the point.

Others stopped sampling. The keyboard and drum machine productions of Timbaland, The Neptunes, Mannie Fresh and the Atlanta trap producers owed something to taste and something to budgets, since a track with no samples has nothing to clear and keeps all its publishing income. Where samples remained, ownership of the new song was often shared with or surrendered to the original writers. The mixtape, distributed outside normal retail, became the place where uncleared material could still be used, which is one reason so many mixtapes never reached shops or streaming services.

Chopping, sample packs and the present

Producers who kept sampling learned to transform their sources. To chop a sample is to cut it into short slices and replay them in a new order from the pads of a sampler. DJ Premier reduced records to stabs of a note or two and rebuilt them as new riffs. Pete Rock filtered bass lines out of jazz records and laid horn phrases over them, and RZA used detuned piano fragments and film dialogue for the Wu-Tang Clan. J Dilla took the method furthest on Donuts in 2006, where slices a fraction of a second long make familiar soul records stutter and sing new melodies.

Software removed the technical limits, and a market grew to route around the legal ones. Composers now record original music designed to be sampled and sell it in royalty-free packs or license it for a share of the song, and subscription libraries offer vast numbers of loops and drum sounds. A melodic loop obtained online, with drums added by a second producer, is the starting point of many current hits, a trade described under type beat. Sampling of old records continues at both ends of the market, licensed at great expense by stars and pressed without clearance in short runs by underground producers.