Crate Almanac

History, chapter 5 of 9

Coast to coast: hip hop from 1993 to 1997

From 1993 to 1997 hip hop was organized by geography. Death Row made Los Angeles the commercial center, New York recovered with a run of debut albums that still define the sound of the city, and a rivalry between the two was fed by magazines and award shows until it was overtaken by the killings of Tupac Shakur and The Notorious B.I.G. Away from both coasts, artists in Atlanta, Houston, Memphis, New Orleans and the Midwest built their own industries, and an independent underground took shape.

Death Row and G-funk

The Chronic dominated radio and MTV through 1993, and Death Row Records, run by Suge Knight with Dr. Dre as its producer and distributed by Interscope Records, followed it in November with Doggystyle by Snoop Doggy Dogg, which entered the Billboard 200 at number one. G-Funk spread through Warren G, whose "Regulate" with Nate Dogg was a major hit of 1994, and Tha Dogg Pound, while E-40 and Too Short sold a related funk-based sound from Northern California.

The label's success made it a political target. Congressional hearings on gangsta rap were held in 1994, and a campaign led by C. Delores Tucker and William Bennett pressed Time Warner to sell its stake in Interscope in 1995. Eazy-E died of complications of AIDS in March 1995. That October Knight signed Tupac Shakur, whose All Eyez On Me (1996) was a double album and an enormous seller. Dr. Dre left the label in 1996 to start Aftermath Entertainment.

The New York revival

The Wu-Tang Clan, nine rappers from Staten Island and Brooklyn led by the producer RZA, released Enter The Wu-Tang (36 Chambers) on Loud Records in November 1993. Its sound was raw: clipped soul samples, detuned piano and dialogue from kung fu films. The group's contract left each member free to sign elsewhere as a solo artist, and albums by Method Man, Ol' Dirty Bastard, Raekwon, GZA and Ghostface Killah followed on several labels between 1994 and 1996.

In 1994 two debut albums restored the city's standing. Illmatic by Nas, from Queensbridge, set compressed, observant verses over beats by DJ Premier, Pete Rock, Large Professor and Q-Tip. Ready To Die by The Notorious B.I.G. combined autobiography, menace and humor with radio singles such as "Juicy". The Infamous (1995) by Mobb Deep and records by Black Moon and Gang Starr deepened the hard, sample-based sound that KRS-One had named on his 1993 album Return Of The Boom Bap, the style tagged Boom Bap.

Jay-Z, from Brooklyn, could not get a recording contract, so he founded Roc-A-Fella Records with Damon Dash and Kareem Burke and released Reasonable Doubt on it in 1996. Lil' Kim and Foxy Brown released debuts in 1996 that went platinum. The city's infrastructure mattered too: Hot 97 became a full-time hip hop station, the Stretch Armstrong and Bobbito show on college radio aired unsigned talent, and DJs such as Ron G and DJ Clue sold mixtapes that broke new records.

Bad Boy, hip hop soul and the remix

Sean Combs, known as Puffy, learned the business at Uptown Records, where he shaped What's The 411? (1992) by Mary J. Blige, whose R&B singing over rap beats was named hip hop soul. He founded Bad Boy Entertainment in 1993 and launched it with Craig Mack and The Notorious B.I.G. Combs treated the remix as a new record, with a different beat and guest verses, and rap verses on R&B singles, the territory of the RnB/Swing tag, became routine.

In 1997 Bad Boy records held the top of the Billboard Hot 100 for much of the year. Their method was to loop the most recognizable part of a 1980s pop or soul hit under a rap verse and a sung hook, and to present it in glossy videos, many directed by Hype Williams. No Way Out by Puff Daddy and Harlem World by Mase sold in the millions. Critics complained of formula, but the approach made rap the default sound of American pop radio.

The Source Awards and two killings

Rivalry between the coasts was sharpened by the press. At the Source Awards on August 3, 1995, Knight mocked Combs from the stage, the crowd booed West Coast and Southern winners, and Andre of OutKast told the audience that the South had something to say. Shakur, who had been shot and robbed at a Manhattan studio in November 1994, came to blame people around Bad Boy, which they denied. After joining Death Row he attacked The Notorious B.I.G. by name on "Hit 'Em Up" in 1996.

On September 7, 1996, Shakur was shot in a car in Las Vegas; he died six days later, aged 25. On March 9, 1997, The Notorious B.I.G. was shot dead in Los Angeles, aged 24. His double album Life After Death was released 16 days later. Neither case had produced a conviction when, in 2023, a man was charged with the murder of Shakur; a Las Vegas jury convicted him in August 2026. No one has been convicted of killing The Notorious B.I.G. The killings ended the feud and left Death Row in decline as Knight went to prison for a probation violation.

The South and Midwest find a voice

The same years brought the South into view. In Atlanta the production team Organized Noize produced OutKast, whose Southernplayalisticadillacmuzik (1994) and ATLiens (1996) appeared on LaFace Records, and Goodie Mob, whose Soul Food (1995) gave currency to the phrase Dirty South. Jermaine Dupri's So So Def had hits with Da Brat. In Houston UGK released Ridin' Dirty (1996), Scarface recorded for Rap-A-Lot Records, and DJ Screw sold slowed-down tapes that founded the Screw style.

Memphis had a dark, lo-fi tape scene from which Three 6 Mafia emerged with Mystic Stylez (1995), while 8Ball & MJG recorded for Suave House. In New Orleans Master P moved his No Limit Records home from California and signed a distribution agreement with Priority that left him ownership of his recordings; he sold millions of albums, including Ghetto D (1997). Cash Money Records was building a roster on Bounce rhythms. Southern labels of this kind stayed independent far longer than their Northern counterparts.

The Midwest developed fast, tuneful styles of its own. Bone Thugs-N-Harmony of Cleveland, signed by Eazy-E to Ruthless Records, harmonized rapid verses on E. 1999 Eternal (1995), and "Tha Crossroads" was a number one single in 1996. In Chicago Twista, Do Or Die and Crucial Conflict rapped in double time, while Common made the reflective Resurrection (1994). Detroit had Esham, a founder of Horrorcore. By 1997 no single city could claim to define the music.

Fugees, Missy Elliott and Timbaland

Not everything fit the regional story. The Fugees, a New Jersey trio of Lauryn Hill, Wyclef Jean and Pras Michel, mixed rapping, singing, reggae and soul on The Score (1996), which sold many millions of copies worldwide and won the Grammy for Best Rap Album. The Roots, from Philadelphia, performed and recorded as a live band. Both showed that an audience existed for hip hop that stood apart from the coastal rivalry.

A more radical change in sound came from Virginia. Missy Elliott, a songwriter and rapper from Portsmouth, and the producer Timbaland wrote and produced much of One In A Million (1996) for the singer Aaliyah and then Elliott's own Supa Dupa Fly (1997). Timbaland's beats used stuttering kick drums, rapid hi-hats, unusual sound effects and large silences, and depended on almost no samples. With the videos that Hype Williams directed for Elliott, they offered a playful, futuristic alternative to both street reporting and nostalgia.

The independent underground and the compact disc

A self-declared underground formed around independent twelve-inch singles. In New York Bobbito Garcia's Fondle 'Em Records and the new Rawkus issued records by Company Flow, whose Funcrusher Plus (1997) made independence a principle, and by Mos Def. In California Solesides and Stones Throw Records did the same, and in Minneapolis Rhymesayers Entertainment began in 1995. Endtroducing..... (1996) by DJ Shadow, made almost entirely from samples and released by the London label Mo Wax, linked this world to Instrumental hip hop and to British Trip Hop.

The commercial format of the period was the compact disc, which had overtaken the cassette early in the decade. Its capacity encouraged albums of 70 minutes or more and then double albums: All Eyez On Me, Life After Death and Wu-Tang Forever all appeared within 16 months. Vinyl survived as a tool for DJs, and cassettes remained the medium of mixtapes and of the Southern tape trade. Rap sales climbed through the decade, and by the end of 1997 hip hop was positioned for the boom described in the next chapter.

Key records

Records from these years that the chapter turns on, in order of release. Titles link to the full entry on Discogs.

Key artists and labels

The era in the catalog

Records per year, with 1993-1997 marked

Year Records
197953
1980252
1981233
1982340
1983585
1984977
19851,072
19861,314
19871,661
19882,374
19893,044
19904,088
19914,738
19925,099
19936,015
19947,013
19958,316
19969,531
199710,746
199812,780
199913,925
200014,785
200115,282
200215,177
200316,346
200417,721
200517,697
200616,987
200715,939
200815,302
200914,759
201014,575
201115,042
201216,034
201315,803
201416,128
201517,096
201618,309
201719,464
201819,959
201920,158
202022,204
202118,440
202215,189
202311,838
20243,766
20252,621
2026913

Styles

Style Records Share
Gangsta6,46516%
RnB/Swing4,81912%
Pop Rap4,21310%
House3,7389.0%
Euro House3,1537.6%
Contemporary R&B2,6826.4%
Pop Rock2,4575.9%
G-Funk2,3275.6%

Labels with the most records

Label Records
Columbia840
Epic594
BMG565
MCA Records551
Virgin514
Mercury471
RCA457
EMI434
Priority Records419
EastWest371

Artists with the most records