Crate Almanac

Guides

Formats

Every period of hip hop has had a format that fit it. The twelve-inch single served the DJ, the cassette served the car and the street, the CD served the long album of the 1990s, and the file and the stream removed the object altogether. This guide describes each in turn and the reasons for its rise and fall. Charts drawn from the catalog follow the text and show the same story in figures.

The twelve-inch single

Rap began on the twelve-inch single, a format the disco industry had introduced in 1976. Its wide grooves allowed more volume and bass than a seven-inch and room for a long track, and "Rapper's Delight" used all of it. For the first five years the single was the whole business. Small labels such as Sugar Hill Records, Enjoy Records, Tommy Boy and Profile Records sold to DJs and to shops near the clubs, and few rappers were thought able to fill an album.

The twelve-inch also set the form of the release. A typical pressing carried the vocal version, an instrumental and often an acapella, spread over an A-side and B-side; some B-sides became better known than the track they backed. Because DJs needed two copies to cut between, the format sold in pairs. It remained the working currency of hip hop DJs through the 1990s, and independent labels used it to introduce artists long after major labels had lost interest.

The album: LP and cassette

Albums came slowly. Kurtis Blow released one on a major label in 1980, but the LP became central only with the debut of Run-DMC in 1984 and the multi-platinum sales of Raising Hell and Licensed To Ill by the Beastie Boys two years later. From then on the album was the unit by which artists were judged and paid. The two sides of an LP, about 20 minutes each, shaped sequencing, and sleeve credits gave producers and guests a visibility they lacked on singles.

For listeners the cassette mattered more than vinyl. It was cheap, it could be copied at home, and it played in cars, portable stereos and personal players. Whole regional scenes were built on it: Bay Area rappers sold tapes from car trunks, Memphis and Houston ran on locally duplicated cassettes, and the mixtape took its name from the format. The cassette single, sold in a cardboard sleeve, was the main singles format in American shops around 1990.

The CD, the maxi-single and the remix

The CD overtook the cassette in the early 1990s and held until the mid 2000s, the period of hip hop's largest sales. A disc could carry almost 80 minutes, and albums grew to fill it, with more tracks, a skit between songs and bonus cuts; double CDs such as All Eyez On Me and Life After Death counted twice toward sales certifications. Because some large retailers would not stock albums carrying the Parental Advisory label, many titles also exist in a clean version.

Singles changed with the format. The maxi-single, on CD or twelve-inch, gathered a radio edit, an album version, instrumentals and one or more remixes, and in the 1990s the remix often became a new record with a different beat and guest verses, a practice Sean Combs made a specialty at Bad Boy Entertainment. Labels also began to withhold commercial singles so that buyers had to purchase the album. Vinyl survived as a format for DJs and collectors.

Promos, white labels and bootlegs

A parallel layer of records never went on general sale. A promo is a pressing sent free to radio and club DJs ahead of release, often with instrumentals and acapellas that the shop edition lacked. A white label is a record with a blank or minimal label, used for test pressings, for advance copies and for releases whose makers preferred not to be identified. The reaction to a promo could decide whether a single received a full release.

The same plain packaging served the unofficial trade. Unlicensed remixes, blends of one artist's vocal over another's beat, leaked tracks and repressings of rare originals all circulated as white labels, and the bootleg twelve-inch was a fixture of specialist shops. Such records are well documented by collectors, so they appear in the catalog in quantity, frequently under Not On Label, and they help explain why the count of records for a popular artist can far exceed that artist's official discography.

Files and streams

The MP3 file and the file-sharing service Napster, launched in June 1999, broke the link between music and a manufactured object. Sales of CDs fell through the 2000s, the iTunes Store, opened in 2003, sold single tracks again, and for a few years the mobile phone ringtone was a significant product, one that favored short, simple hooks. Free mixtapes distributed as downloads became the main way for new artists to be heard, as described in The mixtape.

Streaming completed the change. Spotify launched in the United States in July 2011, the Billboard 200 began counting streams in December 2014, and by 2017 R&B and hip hop together were the most consumed genre in the country. Payment by the play rewarded long track lists and short songs. For a catalog of records the effect is a thinning: a large share of recent hip hop exists only as files, which are documented less thoroughly than physical releases.

The vinyl revival

While files took over daily listening, vinyl returned as a premium object. Reissue labels restored out-of-print albums, Record Store Day, first held in 2008, created an annual market for limited pressings, and anniversary editions of 1990s classics on colored vinyl became routine. New albums now often receive an LP edition months after their digital release, and for independent artists a short vinyl or cassette run sold directly to fans can earn more than their streams.

The revival is driven by collectors more than DJs, and it has changed what a record is for. Most buyers of a new LP have already heard it online. Because each reissue and variant is documented, older records gain versions every year, while this site counts each master release once, however many pressings exist, so that a much-reissued classic and an obscure single each count as one record. The format charts below should be read with that in mind.

Formats in the catalog

How many of each year's records exist in each format. A record issued on vinyl, cassette and CD counts under all three, so the shares add up to more than 100 percent.

Four formats by year

Year Vinyl Cassette CD Digital All records
19795144053
19802442784252
19812222470233
198232932148340
1983560783015585
19849151834621977
19851,00614252151,072
19861,24718179151,314
19871,538283174291,661
19882,138553486402,374
19892,5601,112958573,044
19903,1301,6741,712684,088
19913,2432,0402,294604,738
19922,9882,4252,485685,099
19933,2312,9593,145696,015
19943,4723,2003,9941007,013
19953,7123,5434,9001268,316
19963,7833,6845,9101449,531
19973,8753,5507,00913910,746
19984,6033,6968,46715212,780
19994,7443,2379,59519413,925
20005,0252,56410,53322414,785
20015,0651,96911,16727215,282
20024,6851,37511,41430815,177
20034,8451,01312,46439716,346
20044,71880413,73660917,721
20054,30551813,95183417,697
20063,41030913,8581,19616,987
20072,74217212,8791,63715,939
20082,14912611,8232,56615,302
20091,65114110,6353,68014,759
20101,6251619,5614,73514,575
20111,5662748,8866,01315,042
20121,8114318,6297,12216,034
20131,9516677,9617,24915,803
20141,9459057,4357,94116,128
20152,1691,1987,2078,78617,096
20162,5141,5636,8539,77418,309
20172,8121,6916,33411,07519,464
20183,1131,8855,85811,57419,959
20193,2771,6295,24712,24720,158
20203,5621,8054,69714,43222,204
20213,4411,7514,11211,27818,440
20223,2511,3623,4268,92715,189
20232,9071,0562,6386,45411,838
20243651013446773,766
202511625242,621
202614512913

Records by format

Format Records Share
CD280,37952%
Digital142,36226%
Vinyl138,28126%
Cassette61,60911%
Video10,6622.0%
Other3,3730.6%

Versions by format

Every version counted separately, so heavily reissued albums weigh more.

Format Versions Share
CD404,82546%
Vinyl231,95026%
Digital155,48117%
Cassette87,0019.8%
Video14,6741.6%
Other1,8410.2%