Crate Almanac

History, chapter 7 of 9

Mixtapes and ringtones: hip hop from 2004 to 2009

From 2004 to 2009 the compact disc declined and nothing had yet replaced it. Hip hop adapted faster than the rest of the industry: unofficial mixtapes became the main route to an audience, ringtones and YouTube turned regional dance records into national hits, and blogs took over from magazines. The South set the commercial pace with crunk, snap and trap, Kanye West and Lil Wayne redefined stardom, and a singing, introspective strain appeared at the end of the decade that would shape the next one.

Kanye West and a change of persona

In February 2004 Speakerboxxx/The Love Below won the Grammy for Album of the Year, and the same week Kanye West, a Chicago producer for Roc-A-Fella Records, released his debut as a rapper. The College Dropout set sped-up soul samples and gospel choirs behind a narrator who was middle-class, self-doubting and funny, and its success showed that a rapper did not need a criminal biography. Late Registration (2005) added orchestral arrangements. His fellow Chicagoans Common and Lupe Fiasco found a similar audience.

The shift was confirmed on September 11, 2007, when Graduation by West and Curtis by 50 Cent were released on the same day and West outsold his rival by a wide margin in the first week. The contest was read as the end of the commercial dominance of gangsta rap. Jay-Z, who had become president of Def Jam Recordings at the end of 2004, returned to recording in 2006, and Nas titled an album Hip Hop Is Dead that year in protest at the state of the mainstream.

The South in command: crunk, snap, Houston and trap

Through the middle of the decade the charts belonged to the South. Lil Jon produced "Yeah!" for the singer Usher in 2004, a Crunk record that spent 12 weeks at number one, and the Memphis veterans Three 6 Mafia won an Academy Award in 2006 for a song written for the film Hustle & Flow. From the west side of Atlanta came snap music, a sparse dance style built on finger snaps; "Laffy Taffy" by D4L reached number one in January 2006, and Dem Franchize Boyz followed.

Houston had its national moment in 2005. "Still Tippin'" by Mike Jones, Slim Thug and Paul Wall, released by the mixtape label Swishahouse, introduced the slow tempos and car culture of the city to MTV, and albums by all three and by Chamillionaire sold strongly. The sound descended from DJ Screw, who had died in 2000, and his chopped and screwed method became a standard remix treatment across the South. UGK reached number one with Underground Kingz in 2007, months before the death of Pimp C.

The longest-lived of these styles was Trap. After T.I. named it, Young Jeezy defined its tone on Let's Get It: Thug Motivation 101 (2005) and Gucci Mane its work rate, releasing mixtapes at a rapid pace, many with the producer Zaytoven. The producers Shawty Redd and DJ Toomp set the template: booming 808 kick drums, rattling hi-hats, and ominous synthesized brass and strings under stories of the drug trade. T.I., recording for his own Grand Hustle label, carried the sound to pop radio with King (2006) and Paper Trail (2008).

Lil Wayne, the mixtape and the Drama raid

No one used the mixtape as fully as Lil Wayne. Between the albums Tha Carter (2004) and Tha Carter II (2005) and afterward he released a stream of unofficial CDs, among them Dedication 2 (2006) with DJ Drama and Da Drought 3 (2007), on which he rapped over the hits of other artists. The exposure cost him nothing in sales: Tha Carter III (2008) sold more than a million copies in its first week and was the best-selling album of the year in the United States.

Mixtapes occupied a legal gray area: labels supplied DJs with material because the discs promoted their artists, yet the discs contained uncleared music and were sold for profit. On January 16, 2007, police working with the trade association of the recording industry raided the Atlanta studio of DJ Drama and Don Cannon, seized tens of thousands of CDs and arrested both men. The case discouraged the retail trade, and the mixtape moved online as a free download through sites such as DatPiff, which had launched in 2005.

Ringtones, YouTube and falling sales

Album sales in the United States fell in most years of the decade, and rap, which had depended on CD buyers, was hit hard. Labels looked for revenue in singles and in ringtones, the short clips that mobile phone users paid to download, a market that peaked around 2007. Songs with a simple chant and an easily copied dance suited the format, and critics dismissed a run of such hits as ringtone rap. Most of the records came from young Southern artists, and the complaint carried regional and generational resentment.

The clearest case was Soulja Boy, a teenager who made "Crank That (Soulja Boy)" at home with inexpensive software, posted it on music and social networking sites, and uploaded a video demonstrating the dance to YouTube, which had launched in 2005. The song was number one for seven weeks in 2007. He had built an audience before any label was involved, and the method, more than the song, was the lasting contribution: self-production, direct distribution and a video made to be imitated became the ordinary way for a new rapper to begin.

The Bay Area, New Orleans and London

In the Bay Area the fast, comic, bass-heavy style called Hyphy grew around Mac Dre and his label Thizz Entertainment; he was shot dead in Kansas City in November 2004, and the movement reached its national peak in 2006 with E-40 and Keak Da Sneak on "Tell Me When To Go". In August 2005 Hurricane Katrina flooded New Orleans and scattered its musicians to Houston, Atlanta and beyond. Juvenile and Lil Wayne addressed the disaster on record, and Bounce spread with the displaced.

In the United Kingdom a new form emerged that owed as much to jungle and UK garage as to American rap. Grime, made at about 140 beats per minute on home computers and spread by pirate radio in east London, produced Wiley, Dizzee Rascal, whose Boy In Da Corner on XL Recordings won the Mercury Prize in 2003, Kano, Lethal Bizzle and the Boy Better Know crew of Skepta and JME. Police restrictions on live events limited its growth, and by 2008 its best-known MCs were making chart pop.

Dilla, Madlib and the independent wing

Independent hip hop narrowed in sales but produced some of the most admired records of the decade. Stones Throw Records released Madvillainy (2004), on which Madlib and MF DOOM recorded as Madvillain, an album of short, hookless tracks and dense wordplay. In February 2006 the label issued Donuts by J Dilla, an instrumental suite of chopped soul records partly assembled in a hospital room; he died three days after its release, aged 32. His loose, off-the-grid drum programming influenced producers and live drummers for the next two decades.

Around them a culture of beat tapes and producer-led shows grew, centered on the Low End Theory club night in Los Angeles, from which Flying Lotus emerged. The Grey Album (2004) by Danger Mouse, an unauthorized blend of Jay-Z and the Beatles, became a test case for sampling in the internet age when fans redistributed it in defiance of a legal demand. Hip hop blogs, which appeared from 2005, replaced magazines and radio as the place where new songs were first heard.

Auto-Tune, 808s & Heartbreak and So Far Gone

T-Pain, a singer and rapper from Florida, made the pitch-correction software Auto-Tune an audible effect from 2005, and Lil Wayne used it on "Lollipop" in 2008. That November Kanye West released 808s & Heartbreak, sung almost entirely through Auto-Tune over the bare drums of the TR-808 and made after the death of his mother. Jay-Z called for an end to the effect on a 2009 single, but the argument was already lost: melody and vulnerability had entered the mainstream of rap.

The artist who drew the consequences was Drake, a Toronto actor turned rapper. His mixtape So Far Gone, given away online in February 2009, moved between rapping and singing over muted, atmospheric production, and one of its songs climbed the Hot 100 while he was still without a recording contract. He signed that summer to Young Money, the label Lil Wayne ran through Cash Money Records, which had also signed Nicki Minaj. With Kid Cudi and others of the blog generation, they set the terms for the next chapter.

Key records

Records from these years that the chapter turns on, in order of release. Titles link to the full entry on Discogs.

Key artists and labels

The era in the catalog

Records per year, with 2004-2009 marked

Year Records
197953
1980252
1981233
1982340
1983585
1984977
19851,072
19861,314
19871,661
19882,374
19893,044
19904,088
19914,738
19925,099
19936,015
19947,013
19958,316
19969,531
199710,746
199812,780
199913,925
200014,785
200115,282
200215,177
200316,346
200417,721
200517,697
200616,987
200715,939
200815,302
200914,759
201014,575
201115,042
201216,034
201315,803
201416,128
201517,096
201618,309
201719,464
201819,959
201920,158
202022,204
202118,440
202215,189
202311,838
20243,766
20252,621
2026913

Styles

Style Records Share
Gangsta11,34412%
Conscious8,0218.2%
Pop Rap7,0437.2%
RnB/Swing6,8376.9%
Electro4,2264.3%
Thug Rap4,2104.3%
Hardcore Hip-Hop4,2054.3%
House4,1734.2%

Labels with the most records

Artists with the most records

Artist Records
DJ Screw204
Jay-Z177
Lil Wayne176
Snoop Dogg173
50 Cent163
Kanye West151
Nas133
Eminem125
The Game120
DJ Whoo Kid113