Crate Almanac

History, chapter 8 of 9

The streaming turn: hip hop from 2010 to 2016

Between 2010 and 2016 the way people listened to music changed, and hip hop changed with it. Free mixtape sites, SoundCloud and then paid streaming services replaced the compact disc, the charts were rewritten to count streams, and regional styles became available to anyone with a connection. Kanye West, Drake, Nicki Minaj and Kendrick Lamar led the mainstream, Chicago drill and Atlanta trap supplied its new sounds, and by the end of the period an album could win a Grammy without ever being sold.

Kanye West, Drake and the new mainstream

The decade opened with Kanye West at his most elaborate. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy (November 2010), recorded largely in Hawaii with a large cast of producers and guests and previewed through free weekly downloads, was received as a masterpiece of maximal production. He followed it with Watch The Throne (2011), a joint album with Jay-Z, and with the harsh, electronic Yeezus (2013). The collaborators he gathered, among them Pusha T, Kid Cudi and Travis Scott, carried his methods elsewhere.

Drake proved the more durable model. On Take Care (2011), made chiefly with the Toronto producer Noah Shebib, he moved between rapping and singing over slow, submerged beats; with his OVO Sound label he made Toronto a center of the genre. His labelmate Nicki Minaj used a repertoire of voices and characters on Pink Friday (2010) and became the most successful woman in rap for a decade. J. Cole of North Carolina, signed to Roc Nation and founder of Dreamville, built a large audience with plain-spoken albums.

Kendrick Lamar and Top Dawg

Top Dawg Entertainment, an independent label founded in Carson, California, in 2004, developed four rappers who recorded together as Black Hippy: Kendrick Lamar, ScHoolboy Q, Jay Rock and Ab-Soul. The independent release Section.80 (2011) won Lamar a deal with Aftermath Entertainment, the label of Dr. Dre, and good kid, m.A.A.d city (2012) told a story of adolescence in Compton with the structure of a film. Its commercial and critical success restored the long narrative album to the center of the genre.

To Pimp A Butterfly (March 2015) went further, setting dense verses about race, fame and depression against live jazz and funk played by musicians from the Los Angeles scene, including Thundercat, Kamasi Washington and Terrace Martin. It arrived during the protests that followed police killings in Ferguson, New York and other cities, and the chorus of its song "Alright" was chanted at demonstrations. Other records of the period addressed the same events, among them work by J. Cole, Vince Staples and Run The Jewels.

The internet collapses the map

For a new generation the internet was the scene. Odd Future, a Los Angeles collective of teenagers led by Tyler, The Creator, gave away self-produced albums through its own website from 2008 and broke through in 2011 with the video for "Yonkers"; its members Earl Sweatshirt and Frank Ocean followed with acclaimed work of their own. Lil B, from the Bay Area, posted hundreds of songs and adopted the hazy beats of the producer Clams Casino, a sound called Cloud Rap.

Regional styles no longer required residence. A$AP Rocky, from Harlem, built his 2011 mixtape Live.Love.A$AP on the slowed tempos of Houston and the dark atmosphere of Memphis, and signed a major-label contract on the strength of two online videos. The Raider Klan of Florida revived 1990s Memphis tape rap, the root of the later Phonk tag. Danny Brown in Detroit, Mac Miller in Pittsburgh and Joey Bada$$ in Brooklyn each found national audiences without the support of local radio.

The delivery system was the free mixtape. Sites such as DatPiff and LiveMixtapes hosted full-length releases at no charge, and much of the important music of the early 2010s, including Acid Rap (2013) by Chance The Rapper and the tapes Future issued in 2014 and 2015, was never sold in shops. SoundCloud became the next platform: anyone could upload a track, and by 2016 a distinct scene of very young artists was forming there. The line between mixtape and album was now a matter of sample clearance and marketing.

Chicago drill

In 2012 attention turned to the South Side of Chicago. Chief Keef, then 16, recorded "I Don't Like" with the producer Young Chop, and its video, filmed in a house and posted to YouTube, drew millions of views. Kanye West remixed the song, a major label signed Keef, and Finally Rich followed that December. The style was called Drill: slow, menacing trap beats under flat, clipped accounts of neighborhood conflict. Lil Durk, King Louie and G Herbo came out of the same circles.

Drill emerged in a year when Chicago recorded more than 500 homicides, and several of its young performers were killed or imprisoned. The music was blamed for violence it described, concerts were discouraged by the authorities, and the argument over whether lyrics document or promote conflict, familiar since the 1980s, was repeated. The other breakout from the city, Chance The Rapper, took an opposite approach with gospel-tinged, exuberant records and a refusal to sign with any label. Drill itself traveled further than anyone expected, as a later chapter describes.

Atlanta trap producers and their voices

Trap became the default sound of rap through a succession of producers working in the software FL Studio. Lex Luger, a teenager from Virginia, supplied the orchestral stabs and rolling hi-hats of Flockaveli (2010) by Waka Flocka Flame. In Atlanta Mike WiLL Made-It, Metro Boomin, Zaytoven and the 808 Mafia collective refined the style, announcing themselves with spoken tags at the start of each track, and DJ Mustard built a sparse Californian counterpart for YG. By mid decade their beats were also the basis of pop and R&B hits.

Over these beats the voice became an instrument of texture. Future sang and rapped through Auto-Tune in a weary slur, most fully on DS2 (2015). Young Thug stretched words into yelps and croons on Barter 6 (2015). Migos, three relatives from the Atlanta suburbs signed to Quality Control Music, popularized the clipped triplet flow with "Versace" in 2013 and filled every gap with an ad-lib. Gucci Mane, 2 Chainz and Rae Sremmurd kept Atlanta at the center, and by 2016 rappers from every region worked in versions of its style.

Streams become sales

Spotify opened in the United States in July 2011. Billboard added streams to its singles chart in 2012 and YouTube plays in 2013, and in December 2014 the Billboard 200 began converting streams into album units. Apple Music launched in June 2015, soon after Jay-Z relaunched the rival service Tidal. In 2016 services competed for temporary exclusives, among them The Life Of Pablo by Kanye West, which was revised after release, and Views by Drake. That year streaming supplied more than half of recorded music revenue in the United States.

Hip hop gained more from the change than any other genre. Its audience was young and listened repeatedly, its artists released music often, and the mixtape habit had already taught fans to expect it without a trip to a shop. In May 2016 Chance The Rapper issued Coloring Book as a stream only, with no physical edition and nothing for sale; it reached the top 10 of the Billboard 200, the Recording Academy changed its rules to admit such releases, and in February 2017 it became the first streaming-only album to win a Grammy.

Independents, Hamilton and the return of vinyl

The new economy also favored independence. Mac Miller topped the album chart in 2011 on an independent label, and Macklemore and Ryan Lewis had number one singles and a contested Grammy win with the self-released The Heist. Run The Jewels, the duo of the Atlanta rapper Killer Mike and the New York producer El-P, gave their albums away as downloads from 2013 and earned their living from concerts, merchandise and vinyl. Vinyl sales had risen every year since the first Record Store Day in 2008, while the CD faded from shops.

Hamilton, a Broadway musical by Lin-Manuel Miranda that told the story of an American founder through rap, opened in 2015; its cast recording, made with members of The Roots, topped the Billboard rap albums chart, and the show won the Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 2016. N.W.A. entered the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame the same year. A Tribe Called Quest released a final number one album in November 2016, months after the death of Phife Dawg. Hip hop ended the period poised to become the most heard genre in the country.

Key records

Records from these years that the chapter turns on, in order of release. Titles link to the full entry on Discogs.

Key artists and labels

The era in the catalog

Records per year, with 2010-2016 marked

Year Records
197953
1980252
1981233
1982340
1983585
1984977
19851,072
19861,314
19871,661
19882,374
19893,044
19904,088
19914,738
19925,099
19936,015
19947,013
19958,316
19969,531
199710,746
199812,780
199913,925
200014,785
200115,282
200215,177
200316,346
200417,721
200517,697
200616,987
200715,939
200815,302
200914,759
201014,575
201115,042
201216,034
201315,803
201416,128
201517,096
201618,309
201719,464
201819,959
201920,158
202022,204
202118,440
202215,189
202311,838
20243,766
20252,621
2026913

Styles

Style Records Share
Instrumental8,8497.8%
Conscious8,1777.2%
Pop Rap6,3535.6%
Trap6,1795.5%
Gangsta5,8315.2%
Experimental5,5874.9%
Hardcore Hip-Hop5,4134.8%
Boom Bap4,9974.4%

Labels with the most records

Artists with the most records